Re: orion RE: ORION Variations

[philip davies <P.Davies@sheffield.ac.uk>]

I am happy to debate almost any theory with anyone, but statements like "we
have no evidence that...' do anger me. We have no evidence that Rochelle
Altmann is not a Martian with three green heads. Since we have no evidence
that Martians cannot disguise their appearance, and learn to behave exactly
like humans, shy shold I believe I am debating with a human being?

So: we have no evidence that scribes write other than by dictation
We have no evidence that all scribes always wrote by dictation

Therefore, we know that sometimes scribes wrote from dictation, and that is all.

Thank you.

Philip R Davies
Department of Biblical Studies
University of Sheffield

---

• Prev by Date: Re: orion dates, method, invitation
• Next by Date: Re: Falsifiability, was Re: orion dss and rabbis
• Prev by thread: orion RE: ORION Variations
• Next by thread: orion RE: ORION Answering Greg D. (Long)
• Index(es):
  • Date
  • Thread